The importance of the sunnah

[TheNabi]

Salaam,

Did the companions of Prophet Muhammad take religious orders *ONLY* from the Quran??

Religious orders? Explain.

Joe

[Ash Shuura]

Did the companions of Prophet Muhammad take religious orders *ONLY* from the Quran??

Salaam,

Is there an answer to a wrong question which its answer will depend on unverifiable evidence?  :wink:

[Eranmad]

Did the companions of Prophet Muhammad take religious orders *ONLY* from the Quran??

Salaam,

Is there an answer to a wrong question which its answer will depend on unverifiable evidence?  :wink:

I think you must be taking Quran as verifiable evidence. If the Quranic verses are evidence for you that I have proof for you.

Religious orders? Explain.

yes Thenabi. I am talking about religious orders.

[TheNabi]

Salaam,

yes Thenabi. I am talking about religious orders.

Then please explain as I asked.

Joe

[rahenijaat1]

Salam and Peace!

I answered this before in an other topic. But those posts where deleted. I came with arabic synonyms for sunnah. There is a way of the messenger if you think logically. When we mulims say in our prayer "guide us on the straight path", we say basically that Allah sends us on the path that our prophet peace be upon him walked.

One way or anotther, there is a way of the messenger. There is a way of ibrahim, luth and all other prophets. There is a way of the members on ths board. You cant deny that.

The way of the Messenger is The Message, indeed.

-----"And on that Day, the wrongdoer will bite on his hands, he will say: "Would that I had taken the way of the Messenger."
-----"O, woe to me, would that I had not taken so and so as a friend."
-----"Certainly, he led me astray from The Reminder after when it had reached me. And Satan was ever to man, a betrayer."
-----"And the Messenger will say: "O my Lord, indeed my people had abandoned this Quran." (Al-Furqan-27-30)


The wrong-doer is saying-----"Would that I had taken the way of the Messenger."
And the Messenger is complaining-----"my people had abandoned this Quran."

The wrong-doer is saying the same thing that the Messenger is complaining about.

[Paradox Uncreated]

Obey Mohammed, is not the same as "obey hadith". Why is it that such a statement, should lead to texts outside the Quran? Texts that contain a whole lot of nonsense.

The only thing it can mean, is that Mohammed was obeyed as a leader in his time. Obeying Mohammed was obeying God. And AFAIK, current understanding of hadith, isn`t even this. Mohammed isn`t "inspired" in most hadith, so it is not obeying God, but Mohammed, in some other state.

The more you look at sunnism the more it falls apart.