Quote from: Sania Haque on December 18, 2020, 02:00:03 AM
See here, I am going to disagree with you because as you said it's not necessary that what you think evil is also perceived in the same way by others. I have already answered your question so i donot know what you want me to say now. Artificial insemination is not haram. It's not prohibited. At least bring some coherent arguement here. Anecdotes and personal opinions donot form the laws of Quran. I can whine that breastfeed a kid doesn't makes you that kid's mother but if Allah has ordained it then this is the law we have to follow it. You can give 1000s of reasons why something can be exploited and can be a crime but if Quran doesn't have any evidences against it then that thing cannot be prohibited. Simple
Peace...
Remember Sania if you say another that you can't forbid one thing at the same time you can't allow it as well for yourself, coz QURAN has not allowed it literally .. If you allow it is your own opinion only as well.. Not Quran's.. ...to avoid and reject, Quran verses should be compared... BTW I never referred artificial insemination of wedded couple.. I know what surrogacy is.. Lol..
Okay.. Let me bring some similar questions...
1...Can one have sex before marriage with his boy friend ?
2... Can one have sex willingly with a prostitute .. Coz it is their body and both consent for pleasure?
3... Can one watch porn? And watch porn and do sex?
4... Can one act/play a role in porn video for fun for money?
5... Can one do profession of prostitution willingly?
6.... Can one be a pimp?
7... Can one have anal sex with wife without her consent?
8... Can one have homosex since he or she is naturally addicted to homosex instead of?
9... Can one kiss a girl with her permission...
10...can one take another's help to get his masturbation done?
11... Can one have sex with animals of their choice.. If animal seems interested in it... ?
12... Can one sell his kidney etc since offer is so high while living?
13...can one have sex with robots, gadgets etc.. Etc
14... Can one live without marriage but as couple ciz of not being able take responsibilities of wedded life .. Can they live shifting their partners at will... Etc etc
Above such questions and such acts not harm anyone literally coz they do with consent... If you try direct orders from Quran I am afraid you won't find.
Purpose of evil and purpose of good play a huge role to identify things crystal clearly...
9:67 "The hypocrite men and hypocrite women are of one another. They enjoin what is wrong and forbid what is right and close their hands. They have forgotten Allah , so He has forgotten them [accordingly]. Indeed, the hypocrites - it is they who are the defiantly disobedient"
9:112 "..... those who enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong, and those who observe the limits of Allah. And give good tidings to the believers."
As I said earlier, God has not listed out every Evil and every good act.. It is believers who perceive them within Quran with the magnitude of act.. Failing to perceive Quran results in allowing them.. For example has God forbidden the flesh of human being for consumption? Coz only 4 things God has forbidden in which human flesh is not included... Unless you don't understand the tone of Quran you can say God has not forbidden human flesh then who the hell you are to forbid it and you also a sectarian ..
Evil is self perception and comparison of verses and outcome of act etc...
Likewise God didn't forbid homosex marriage...but comparisons allow you to perceive that it is evil.. Needless for God to mention such a common sense..
For you your way and for me my way... I am responsible for what I do and what I avoid.. And yours is your choice.
Little tip.. Find out thoroughly the evil in an act before avoiding it or allowing in one's own life not for others ..
Laws are equal to all. If surrogacy OR homosex is allowed for one and it should be allowed to all..
If suurgacy is allowed coz the technology is developed now, so, best way a surrogacy could be practices in the ancient time is taking the permission of barren wife by husband and have sex with surrogate mother until she conceives.. And take the baby... And why surrogacy is allowed now and not before in whay is possible for them ..
If a mother of daughter agrees to bear the created embryo, in fact she gives a birth to a child and she becomes grand mother of her own delivered child.. Though biologically grandchild is not her own coz eggs and sperm is her daughter's and son in law ... What a shame?
If such acts are very reasonable then advise to people to carry out and be responsible for what you advised.. Coz your only criteria is QURAN not forbidden..so allow human flesh as well coz not forbidden