Quote from: good logic on October 08, 2018, 07:15:08 AM
What I am saying to you is simple and straightforward. It is of no use to anyone if they are going to guess where you get the meaning of the roots from!
I said nothing about where to get the root meanings from. You've mentioned word 'roots' several time already, as it somehow was my point. Root meaning are archetypal for the most part, yet a root combination from where a word meaning is derived itself is cultural for the most part and is induced by higher religious-linguist authorities, which the Project Root List copies from.
What you are saying is profane and your conclusions come from a complete lack of insight and are based on a 100% straightforward/literal way to receive and handle received information, which your previous post shows, which I could not even reply to due to how it completely missed the point.
Quote from: good logic on October 08, 2018, 07:15:08 AM
Also why is your source of knowledge better than the lexicons and the Arabic dictionaries?
First reply to my questions on Muhammad. I asked you 7 simpliest questions, do not think you have a right to ask anything until you prove your OWN coherent understanding of the book you claim to be divine.
Quote from: good logic on October 08, 2018, 07:15:08 AM
Surely Arabic is not that complicated?
You mean the language forged in 8-9th centuries with 12 additional letters which were never part of original abjad script and loads of loan words and weird grammar rules?
Quote from: good logic on October 08, 2018, 07:15:08 AM
I am genuinely asking you to provide some source if you want to share it with others
I genuinely ask you use common sense, otherwise there is no use of explaining anything.
Quote from: good logic on October 08, 2018, 07:15:08 AM
I believe Qoran to be the word of GOD
So are the Talmud and the Ancient Greek philosophies from where some stories which have made it into the Quran are based on, right (the story of Ibrahim idol shop and the story of Seven Sleepers respectively)?
Quote from: good logic on October 08, 2018, 07:15:08 AM
, I have my solid proof.
The 19 multiplier of the Iinitial Letters?
That is not your "solid proof", it was discovered by someone else you simply eat what you were provided with on your table. Try making a new discovery by first removing a veil which covers your eyes, ears and heart and then start looking for clues.
And what does number 19 mean to you? If you don't know its meaning then it's a worthless knowledge which has not lead you anywhere. What is the meaning of letters themselves? If you do not know the meaning of the letters you calculate, what is the point?