Stoning the three pillars during Haj|

[357]

It is said As Abraham was going for the sacrifice the devil tried to stop him three times, and each time Abraham throw stones at the devil! practice carried out by stoning the thre three pillars during Haj.


Please explain it , those who believe this.

Thanks You.

Such sacrifices are carried out in india......................so they say to please Their Godess 

I believe it is totally and utterly barbaric, what do you say?

[imrankhawaja]

if they think its ibless who they are stoning then, ibless shaitan mardood must be laughing on them
if they think its devil then , they have to stone their inside too.. (thats why some people have stones in their stomachs)   

once a person fell sick during hajj and he called to his homeland and advising them to give money on the name of data ganj baksh darbar and abdul qadir jilani(11th one)  so that he may recover   

sometimes why i think the people who are blindly follow their teachings , dnt they have a little common sense to see what they are doing .. just one time read of quran will give them lot of answers like , the dead cant help us, nobody is above God , and nobody is able to bring ships out of sea other than God.. but people still believe its ( abdul qadir jilani) who manage to save ships from sea..

how come somebody b so stupid ? or headless  ? why dnt they think or ponder on this basic thing?
even the qualified doctors, teachers and highly intelligent people of our society are doing this shirk thingie why?

[Novice]

It is said As Abraham was going for the sacrifice the devil tried to stop him three times, and each time Abraham throw stones at the devil! practice carried out by stoning the thre three pillars during Haj.

Salaam

What do you mean by IT IS SAID. Who said it?

We should not follow folklore. These bedtime stories are of no value. God does not play games with its creation.

[Amra94]

I believe it is totally and utterly barbaric, what do you say?

I agree brother. Nobody here believes that story..

[Wakas]

I recommend:
https://free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=13069.msg273059#msg273059

[357]

Salaam

What do you mean by IT IS SAID. Who said it?

We should not follow folklore. These bedtime stories are of no value. God does not play games with its creation.

Well that is the common belief behind , why we stone the three pillars on haj, if one doesn't believe in the Haj that is different matter of course.

[357]

I was talking to a relative and i asked him;

if you hear a voice or have a dream to slaughter your child to please God will you  - he said most definately 

[imrankhawaja]

I was talking to a relative and i asked him;

if you hear a voice or have a dream to slaughter your child to please God will you  - he said most definately 

what if that dream comes from satanic forces who use the same medium what angelic forces use..(never think that way)

if he share that dream with his son , then i will let you know next steps..
the son will sacrifice his father in the name of ibless.. its called a self defence 

apart from joking the sacrifice is not to slaughter the son it was actually a kind of migration or a noble cause
same like when we send our kids to getting better education
and we send our kids to somewhere they can earn more money than normal etc..

God does not order immorality ...
satanic forces see you from where you dnt see them , thats y this tradition is blindly in our faith becoz we did not try to understand that event by critical thinking..

on the other hand if God will to do something there is nothing that can stop God..
he will not ask you to do , he will make it happen according to his will.. he is supreme controller of everthing that exist.
people died in earthquakes, nation died by God punishments, volcanoes, storms, tsunami, diseases, hunger.. accidents..

i wonder some people even blame God for this.. he clearly created life and death becoz this is important , you only realise the value of death when somebody old becoem a responsibilty on you.. and you wish that God take him away..

he creates every situation for his creation to ponder about his actions..

look that "ART" inside you .. you exist and he create that art to think about you, about your nature, about all this life and death..
clearly by critical thinking i feel this is the work of the supreme artist who paint all this with reason..
to him i    more i think more i    ..

[HP_TECH]

I was talking to a relative and i asked him;

if you hear a voice or have a dream to slaughter your child to please God will you  - he said most definately 

Your relative is only talking. Obedience is demonstrated.
Seek God's Help in guiding you to the right understanding then go back and read the passages related.

[good logic]

Peace 357.
You are a member here for many years. We have discussed this topic numerous times. All you have to do is search and read our views,those who have stayed here with you.
I have asked you in the past about your polls,and you did not give me an answer ,as far as I can recall,if so, please link your answer here. Also,you have never given us any feedback on your polls or discussed your findings with us,to my knowledge.

I have commented on your polls before,they do not serve any purpose whatsoever. Without proper analysis and proper researched choices that will tell you and the readers something useful,they are a waste of time!
Sorry for pointing out to you my view,I feel you can use the forum better if you explain your aim of doing such polls for your topics and give us your view as well on the topics.
GOD bless you.
Peace.