News:

About us: a forum for monotheists, and discussion of Islam based on The Quran

Main Menu

classic (literal ) translation of 2:31

Started by ansi, April 22, 2007, 06:25:25 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

progod

Peace,

In my opinion, al-bashar, adam and even al-waraa are all names for Humanity. Adaam is a proper name for al-bashar/al-Insaan/al-ins and al-waraa (which is not in the Quran).

And so banoo adami just refers to Aadamu just as banoo isra'eela refers to isra'eelu.

I considered this at one time as well. But although we are in clay right now, al-insaan, al-bashar or Aaadamu is more than this clay and will exist after this clay. So whether the angels were told to pay respects when we were physical or before we were physical makes no difference. You are confusing the issue of bowing in devotion to physical statues with paying respects to real beings (which even the stars and sun can do as Joseph's dream shows us God bless him and keep him). When Joseph's parents sajadoo to him they may have been prostrating or they may just have been paying respects without prostrating. In Africa in some Muslim regions (the hausa) people still physically bow down (prostrate) to the king. They are just paying respects, this does not mean that they view him as God.(although I don't agree kingship). It is the Muslim view that we shall not bow to anyone who is not God as a symbolic gesture, but this is an empty gesture if we serve anything or devote ourselves to anything in a way that we are only to serve God and devote ourselvs to Him.

Godbless,
Anwar
The Quranists Must Rise!

[url="http://www.quranists.com"]http://www.quranists.com[/url]

Iyyaka

Quote from: ansi on April 22, 2007, 06:25:25 PM
please can any one who understand Arabic explain the literal translation  of WA allama adama asama...2;31.
I refer you to the link below on the influence of certain Jewish traditions in circulation (oral and/or written?) at the time of the prophet Muhammad (pbsl).
Note: influence does not necessarily mean "copy and paste".

For the verse (2:31 and the following ones which are linked to it) which is the subject of this topic, I refer you to page 42-43 of the pdf or to the chapter "the fall of satan" of this book :
http://www.dominiopublico.gov.br/download/texto/gu001493.pdf

God bless you.
[url="https://reveniraucoran.fr/"]https://reveniraucoran.fr/[/url]