News:

About us: a forum for monotheists, and discussion of Islam based on The Quran

Main Menu

Earth's Water Likely Came from Very Early Asteroid Strikes

Started by zayd, October 27, 2013, 08:09:58 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Man of Faith

Hello Study,

I wrote most and not synonymous, but as you say it may not even be most. The prevalence of atheism in many science branches may be high though.

They might not adhere to primitive faiths though as their intellect may protect them from that ignorance and irrationality. I wrote in certain posts that the worldly portrayal of Rabb may turn them off too and so to say do theism a disservice. Smart people require more plausible explanations or they will simply not swallow the proposed concept.

Personally what turned me off from conventional Islam was just that and that the god seems awfully primitive and uses a grand portion of a writing to boast about its own greatness. I mean, it does what it tells others (its "slaves") to do not. To my relief Quran and Rabb revealed to me that account simply was not true, the common interpretation simply is a crazy fabrication, but it does however mislead a multitude of people with what does not help anyone of them and it misrepresents Rabb severely, which really interpreted texts would better appeal to atheists if they knew what it really conveyed.

Be well
Amenuel
Website reference: [url="http://iamthatiam.boards.net"]http://iamthatiam.boards.net[/url]

Student of Allah

Quote from: zayd on October 28, 2013, 10:57:43 PM
Salaam and hello.

The Quran says that God sends down water from the sky as a mercy and a blessing, and I?ve always understood this as rain from the clouds, but I've never thought that it could also be understood as water from outer space! (This could be common knowledge, but I didn?t know, LOL!) So when I saw the article, I just had to share it with someone!

After reading the article and doing some searches in the Quran, I noticed that the sending down of water from the sky is also mentioned with the creation of the heavens and the Earth, the creation of the sun and the moon, the creation of plants and creatures, and the Resurrection.



7:26    O Children of Adam, We have sent down for you garments to alleviate your bodies, and feathers; and the garment of righteousness is the best. That is from the signs of God, perhaps they will remember.

Now, you have 2 options:

1. Understand that the use of "sent down" in the Qur'an cannot be used as positive proof of things arriving to earth from outer space.
2. Accept that garments came to earth from outer space.


Actually, there is a 3rd option. You can simply be dishonest and cherry pick. You can scream Allahu Akbar and talk about the scientific accuracy of the Qur'an when it talks about iron/water being sent down but just take the verse about the garment on to be something metaphorical.


Peace
----------------- Student of Allah
[url=http://studentofallah.blogspot.com/]"Student of Allah"'s blog[/url]

imrankhawaja

what do you know what outer space is,,,, what do you know what was there before big bang,,,, smoke yeh,,, its mention already in quran,,, what was before smoke,,, the power of Allah,,, the rulling of ALLAH THE KINGDOM OF Allah...

what was before you and after you ,,, only Allah know,,,

you are talking about garments ,as a whole I can say everything what earth creates comes from outer  space 13.7 billion years ago.. even if you multiply this billions into trillions Allah was there... huh,,, talking about garments,,,

to him belong whatever is in the heavens and earth and whatever is between them... can you see a ending and starting of a movie at same time. huh,,,, talking about garments...

keep your scientific theories and facts onto you  dnt try to calculate the highness of Allah  with these shit things...

becoz,,, Allah is above from what they associate with him.. you can only imagine things having space time matter and Allah is above from all of them... huh talking about garments...

for me this universe is just a creation of almighty soon your science get advance and it will discover more things not only garments... Dis cover... its mean it is alrwady there just need to dis its cover... quran tell the scientific truths ages ago interestingly most of them are dis-covered by athiests.. Hawkins is big atheist but he believes in expanding universe strange...  next time try to get prepare more accurately while challenging quran.

peace... and after this verse 7 26 there is another verse for the people like you...

O children of Adam, let not Satan tempt you as he removed your parents from Paradise, stripping them of their clothing to show them their private parts. Indeed, he sees you, he and his tribe, from where you do not see them. Indeed, We have made the devils allies to those who do not believe. 7 27...






imrankhawaja

another thing,, I m disappppinted by options... just two three.... awww I was thinking there are multiple options like trees mountains,, organic and inorganic matters... come  to space now clusters , galaxies, stars, haha

these are options for us and we are unaware about lot of facts regarding these above options

everysingle day even on this planet new species are discovered..

forget about the universe its out of the calculation lol,,,

awww options are limited but the highness of my rab is unlimited,,, let me show you I mean introduce you a little bit more of my lord,,,

if all the trees are pen and all the oceans are the ink ,,,the words of your lord will not run out even if you double the supply of ink...Allah is noble and wise

sura luqman verse 27

see again 27...wao


fye

Everything on this planet is bonded by hydrogen is it not possible, no probable that there was oxygen there too?
And the easiest bond is o2 but the hydrogen is present as well from molten rock in luiquid form liquid like water is liquid that water and sky are just byproducts of the earth of the earth?

Or did NASA catch any photos of angels 28th jugs of water in emptiable pitchers? Or is there a manager Angel with a human son Or whatever nonsense you come up with.

Seriously flat earth, sphereucal atoms
Praise be to ALLAH
my friend and only friend