https://youtube.com/watch?v=H1BWWnrDa8MRefuting Mufti Menk Sunnah of the Prophet
Peace.
Today I decided to watch this lecture of Mufti Menk, an "A list" Sunni cleric, beneficial for people who see clearly this man is astray. I only want to discuss the Ayahs he bought up in his extreme love for the Messenger-Prophet Muhammad and his alleged "Sunnah".
He quoted Surah 62:2, In which this man completely split and gave an "expounding" Sunni "interpretation" I've not heard before, again he's "A" list, not some person who's not "authorised" by the high end clerics in the Saudi regime.
He presents this Ayah as the Sunnah which is a "gift" from Allah Ta Ala.
We all know "kitabi wal hikmati" is one thing, "bihi" in Surah 2:231 which clarifies this.
This "Wa" in Arabic is gathering, unrestrictedly, not making two separate authorities as understood by Sunnis, "obey Allah and his Messenger" Ayahs they use to make Sunnah.
In Surah 9:1 for example the dissociation is from Allah & his messenger, not two separate dissociations.
He goes to extremes in his sanctifying of the seal of the Prophets, Muhammad, who is free and far from all these false allegations against him.
I love the Prophet, but I DO NOT give him "rights & ranks" that THE GOD has not given him, nor authorised. An example would be as the Mufti quotes "Muhammad, the best of creation!"
Moreover, still on Surah 62:2 which he didn't reference, he goes into claiming that Muhammad, the man, how he lived, what he said, what he did, how he spoke etc... The Sunnah as a "package gift" being an extra gift with the Quran, it's sad how he recites the Ayahs to "adore Muhammad rather then THE LORD.
I learnt also that Sunnis "see Muhammad in dreams" and the clerics have a method to tell if you actually saw the Prophet or not, of course based on specific criterion of him found in books of, yes, your correct Hadith.
He quotes many "classic" Sunni arguments, I want to listen again and post the other arguments he presented, to be continued...
If you watched it, kindly post your refutations.
Please only stick to discussing the Ayahs he puts forward, no point in making another thread discussing Hadith.
Please only stick to refuting Mufti Menk on this lecture of his, using ONLY the Quran to counter.
Please don't violate these 2 very fair terms.
Peace free-minds,
Non Mushrik.
