peace all,
Mazhar,
I can only assume you are attempting to make a link between "salat" mentioned in those verses and "SJD", or are implying I am deterring others from the "salat". If the former, it is weak and unevidenced, and if the latter, then simply untrue, as I recommend the "salat".
Hasan,
I can only assume you made up the part about there being other special units spread around (which I assume do not establish the salat), AND that the prophet being called a perfect commander, as there is no evidence for either. I should have been clearer, my article is based on what AQ actually says, not make believe.
ths,
The so-called "absence of logic" you mentioned fails to take into account the internal logic and coherence of AQ which helps us narrow down meanings and give us the most likely answer. It is a pity that in your article you failed to give a response to many of the sjd=prostration problems highlighted in this forum and in the article above.
I do not mind you claiming that I have no knowledge of Arabic, but you should be more accurate, I know "almost zero" Arabic. Of course, this has very little relevance to whether an understanding is correct however, as the proof is in the pudding, as they say.
####
It is heartening to see that Mazhar, Hasan and ths who presumably hold the view of sjd=prostration resort to ad hominen attacks, unevidenced claims and none tackle any of the points brought up in the article via evidence/logic based discussion. This suggests to me I'm on the right track