News:

About us: a forum for monotheists, and discussion of Islam based on The Quran

Main Menu

How sex before Marriage is not haram (prohibited) according to the Quran

Started by nimnimak_11, January 10, 2010, 03:26:09 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

imrankhawaja

Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 08:02:06 AM
lets just say a guy have it with robot doll

as long those robot moved by it self or by your self and
no other person control it
its considered as your body part,

tools you posses or control is ur body part
like sword that you hold is considered as ur bodypart

if two guys use that robot, than it men those robot is their each bodypart
and these verse tell us its okay to use what ur part posses,
tools become ur body part/possesed when u hold it

so as long u have it by ur self, theres no prohibition on that
dont use that bodypart tool with other person together/simultanously


that what i belief

hmm so same right handed robots are rightfully yours if you buy them...

but if a friend want to take favor he can also use that robot... that what you try to say...

in case of animals , what you rightfully own , are we allowed to do sex with them? we  even kill them for eating so why not do sex with them for sex satisfaction? (i want your views on it)

RED nobody can do it brother.. which world you are living in... is it really possible... :o



rararanran

Quote from: imrankhawaja on March 26, 2017, 08:11:12 AM
hmm so same right handed robots are rightfully yours if you buy them...

but if a friend want to take favor he can also use that robot... that what you try to say...

in case of animals , what you rightfully own , are we allowed to do sex with them? we  even kill them for eating so why not do sex with them for sex satisfaction? (i want your views on it)

RED nobody can do it brother.. which world you are living in... is it really possible... :o

first thing first, god did not prohibit polygamy, divorce, gamble, geting drunk, or masturbation
because some people say its haram by god,

but god didnt say its haram
god jst say theres a huge lost u can get from doing that,
which will degenerate ur degree as human being

wait a second i give example, sword u hold n control at ur hand is considered ur body part,
its not about who is buying or own those thing, its a matter who use or control it = thats what i mean by "posses" it, like ghost "posses" a being

and animal? could you really or the one who control or "posess" the animal?
horse? do you control horse and consider that animal as ur body part?

btw its not a car, insted u could have sex with a car u control/possess if u want to hehe

RED its about the future a robot doll, or a doll with two hole
you can buy it, but you prohibited to use it together with other people at the same time
because quran answear all things, past, present or future

imrankhawaja

Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 08:32:44 AM
first thing first, god did not prohibit polygamy, divorce, gamble, geting drunk, or masturbation
because some people say its haram by god,

but god didnt say its haram
god jst say theres a huge lost u can get from doing that,
which will degenerate ur degree as human being

wait a second i give example, sword u hold n control at ur hand is considered ur body part,
its not about who is buying or own those thing, its a matter who use or control it = thats what i mean by "posses" it, like ghost "posses" a being

and animal? could you really or the one who control or "posess" the animal?
horse? do you control horse and consider that animal as ur body part?

btw its not a car, insted u could have sex with a car u control/possess if u want to hehe

RED its about the future a robot doll, or a doll with two hole
you can buy it, but you prohibited to use it together with other people at the same time
because quran answear all things, past, present or future

having a sex with car is recommended . ok i got it...
and about future , we dnt know what is gona happen in near future ... (lets talk about present)

yes you control the horse when you , pull his left chain for taking left turn and right for right turn..
yes horse in in your possession and control... (by the will of God)
even the modern engines in cars are also built through horse power engine measurements ( seems horse is not an ordinary animal)
yes you rightfully own your horse /animals
you can kill them for eat, ride them for transport... and why dnt you just have a sex with them thats what i ask according to your own given logic... ( try to give me answer this time just yes or no)

apart from that...

polygamy, divorce, gamble, geting drunk, or masturbation

in this list add more thing  which are not haram like

lie
dishonesty
cheating
swaering
assaulting


list is bit long ...

but we differentiate things with morality and immorality...

like the way you are discussing is consider as immoral discussion... why immoral becoz some womens are in forum too so for the sake of their respect you need to hold the moralities ..

but yeh for getting knowledge you can aks the questions in immoral way its not haram/prohibted...

people usually consider the word haram as something extra apart from law...
haram is a synonym of a prohibtion or restriction...
in that sense a lie can be haram too
cheating can be haram too
dishonesty can b haram too
disloyalty can be haram too...

depend on how you look the word "haram"

if you want to discuss the word haram we can talk in relevant thread  instead of going offtopic...


imrankhawaja

Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 08:32:44 AM

RED its about the future a robot doll, or a doll with two hole
you can buy it, but you prohibited to use it together with other people at the same time
because quran answear all things, past, present or future

so according to you anal sex is also recomended... ? look your own logic is rolling again and again with new multiple questions...


rararanran

Quote from: imrankhawaja on March 26, 2017, 08:49:00 AM
having a sex with car is recommended . ok i got it...
and about future , we dnt know what is gona happen in near future ... (lets talk about present)

yes you control the horse when you , pull his left chain for taking left turn and right for right turn..
yes horse in in your possession and control... (by the will of God)
even the modern engines in cars are also built through horse power engine measurements ( seems horse is not an ordinary animal)
yes you rightfully own your horse /animals
you can kill them for eat, ride them for transport... and why dnt you just have a sex with them thats what i ask according to your own given logic... ( try to give me answer this time just yes or no)

apart from that...

polygamy, divorce, gamble, geting drunk, or masturbation

in this list add more thing  which are not haram like

lie
dishonesty
cheating
swaering
assaulting


list is bit long ...

but we differentiate things with morality and immorality...

like the way you are discussing is consider as immoral discussion... why immoral becoz some womens are in forum too so for the sake of their respect you need to hold the moralities ..

but yeh for getting knowledge you can aks the questions in immoral way its not haram/prohibted...

people usually consider the word haram as something extra apart from law...
haram is a synonym of a prohibtion or restriction...
in that sense a lie can be haram too
cheating can be haram too
dishonesty can b haram too
disloyalty can be haram too...

depend on how you look the word "haram"

if you want to discuss the word haram we can talk in relevant thread  instead of going offtopic...

dishonesty, dont take oath n promise from them anymore
cheating lets say adultery, lash em in public ( talk about their bad deed in public to make them ashamed)
swaering?? this is not haram
assaulting, its considered transgression do what they did to you in equal
stealing for greed/corruption chop hand
straling because nothing to eat starving to death is not haram

its not about moral or immoral its about which is haram, dont mix those
haram and have punishment for it
punishment by god and by human

quran is science and theres no taboo thing in science 1+1 is 2

so talk about stephen hawking or people with prosthetic or robot hand

recomended?? what i recomend is to abstain from all those animal things the best u can
i recomend to all of you to abstain from sex!

btw anal sex is not prohibited with your supose, wife or husband
how could you tell if im a man or woman?

is that only a man who could talk about these thing??
is woman unable to talk about these?

rararanran

the first haram is something which is zalim thing to other human and god tell us about human realm or other human punishment for it, and prohibition for it

the second is not actually a haram or prohibition thing because this is seomthing that only god who will judge and will punish, so its up to individual to consider gamble, beer, polygamy, divorce,etc is haram or not. god only say about the bad things or cons about those things.

but if people in society make an agreement and regulation about it its okay but just dont take god or prophet name about those regulation, its human regulation

imrankhawaja

Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 09:12:11 AM

btw anal sex is not prohibited with your supose, wife or husband
how could you tell if im a man or woman?




if something is not mention is the list of haram, doesnt necessarily means you are allowed to do it...(in general)
like speaking a lie?
can save a life or speaking a truth can take a life too.. but as i told earlier i dnt want to go  offtopic... (about haram)

its totally morality and immorality always like

dark and light
haram(disallowed/prohibted) and halal(allowed/not prohibted)
neg and positive
good and evil
moral and immoral
right and wrong
true and false like 1+1 = 2 true... =3 false...


BOLD part yeh i dnt know who you are?
but thats not important ...

about anal sex and blowjobs its depends on the moral value of individual i cant comment on it..
but every body really knows the difference between neat and clean , and hygience stuff...
some people are neat and clean while other appeared to take less care about it...

but God like people are who clean (somewhere mention in scripture too)

making anal sex allowed is a big claim without any evidence from quran in hand...

rararanran

Quote from: imrankhawaja on March 26, 2017, 09:44:27 AM
if something is not mention is the list of haram, doesnt necessarily means you are allowed to do it...(in general)
like speaking a lie?
can save a life or speaking a truth can take a life too.. but as i told earlier i dnt want to go  offtopic... (about haram)

its totally morality and immorality always like

dark and light
haram(disallowed/prohibted) and halal(allowed/not prohibted)
neg and positive
good and evil
moral and immoral
right and wrong
true and false like 1+1 = 2 true... =3 false...


BOLD part yeh i dnt know who you are?
but thats not important ...

about anal sex and blowjobs its depends on the moral value of individual i cant comment on it..
but every body really knows the difference between neat and clean , and hygience stuff...
some people are neat and clean while other appeared to take less care about it...

but God like people are who clean (somewhere mention in scripture too)

making anal sex allowed is a big claim without any evidence from quran in hand...

and now you are like a hadist people haraming thing which is not told in quran
who said anal is haram you or god?
even tough i dont like anal and even my self considered it as immoral,
its not prohibited in quran, so dont say if its a haram thing okay

even prophet are not allowed to say haram to something which is not in quran

and who said lying is not haram? the punishment is to not believe those person again
until he ask the other party forgiveness, and test them if he/she is not lie anymore

lying even cause death is a lie, what the difference?? u make it complicated

because moral and immorality is relative but quran is not
everything is already there in detail

Rana Hafiz

This is the severe drawback in the existing translations of the Quran. Unfortunately the whole Quran has been translated without reasoning and even without looking at the words of the Quran. This is correct that Iranian culture and our upbringing has changed the understanding of the Quran and we take each and every statement of the Quran according to our beliefs which could be wrong. The truth should come out whether it matches with our personal belief or not. I appreciate those thoughtful people who do their best to bring out the truth without looking back.

imrankhawaja

Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 09:48:43 AM
and now you are like a hadist people haraming thing which is not told in quran
who said anal is haram you or god?

read my all posts again and tell me a single thing i claim its haram...

i did not claim its haram .

you claim its allowed , burden of proof is on you.. either you bring a reference for your claim it would be sufficent...

i said i consider it as an immoral act and God dnt like immorality...


Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 09:48:43 AM
even tough i dont like anal and even my self considered it as immoral,
its not prohibited in quran, so dont say if its a haram thing okay


well its good you know the  dfference between immoral and moral
thats what we are actually discussing....


Quote from: rararanran on March 26, 2017, 09:48:43 AM
lying even cause death is a lie, what the difference?? u make it complicated



its not complicated i actually told you the moral values of speaking lie and truth according to a situation

example telling a truth to kid about his drawing is horrible is not a moral thing
a person is running for his life.. and hide in your house ,,, and if you speak lie , its a moral thing... u saved a life..