Peace All.
Those who are doing the rounds with subjects from Qoran will notice that some subjects will stay interpreted differently depending on where the "logic / understanding/search/. of the individual.." lies.
Bringing "proofs" can also be pointless, because the past can never be brought with it. So it is each to their proof/fact/...
As for history ,well what can one say ,except there is some history that is agreed on by many but still disputed by others. The devil can sometimes be in the details. And this is where we differ. Can humans tell lies? Of course they can. Can humans distort the truth? Of course they can.. Can history be written and controlled by the "Victors" ? Of course it can.... And so on.
So how are we to check/ use 17:36 on many subjects and issues of the past? Why did Qoran only deal with certain people and sometimes left some details out? One can only say Qoran is not a history book but a message. I will come to my point at the end of this post.
For example if one tried to search Moses history and came up to this:
https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/73398/jewish/Moses.htmDo they believe all of it? Is there any distortions/?...etc.
One can use Qoran to chreck, some details agree but others differ...Then we move on to another side of the same story like for example:
https://www.ancient-origins.net/history-famous-people/moses-0012411And so forth....One can compare /analyse...But still little issues will arise. So what is the solution that gets us to the truth?
This is where I go back to my earlier point that Qoran is a message not a history book first and formost.
What is the message that will unite all its students?
I say it is the call to "Sirat Al Mustaqueem". Qoran has come to unite us on this very important path so that we can live in peace and harmony with each other ,now in our present time.
As for other subjects ,like this one, it does not matter an iota who is right or wrong. The lesson of Moses will give us the motivation to better our lives not where he was or the exact location of the people and place.
Thise who have the truth should be to their own satisfaction,not others. They can only share it ,not ram it down throats..
Brothers and sisters, discuss by all means, but remain united and do not divide because of issues that do not matter.
Yes of course bring in your views, you are all welcome.
GOD bless you all.
Peace.