aidid's errors!

[simple]

Salaams god1quran1, Elke,

The root is actually Ain, Nun, K, B and the t is just making the word feminine- as I see.

Page 392 quranic Dictionary by Abdul Mannam Omar.

Salaams.

[god1quran1]

Salaams god1quran1, Elke,

The root is actually Ain, Nun, K, B and the t is just making the word feminine- as I see.

Page 392 quranic Dictionary by Abdul Mannam Omar.

Salaams.

I do not have access to this dictionary. Can you please provide more details.

thanks and peace.

[Mazhar]

Salam
Thanks mz for referring me to this thread. I have found an answer and perhaps a plausible explanation.
Quran e Majeed has given an example comparing the Psyche of those who adopt "Aulia" (protectors, god fathers) instead of Allah with that of a female spider who also adopts a house. Spiders, female and male, make (manufacture), build separately their webs for the purpose of catching prey. Web is primarily a hunting place not the bait, i.e. house. It is not family mansion, since male and female spider do not live like a family. Male and female of even the same species are careful of each other and come closer for mating after identification. Certain people "Ittakhazoo" others as their "Aulia" and female spider "Ittakhazat" (singular,feminine, past) a house which is weakest of all houses. "Ittakhazat" does not mean making something. It is taking something, adopting. The precision of similarity of attitude could be seen in the house which female spider adopts:

The females of many species place the egg sac on a stalk, wraps leaves
about it, attach it to a stone, or cover it with smooth silk before abandoning it. Other females guard the egg sac or carry it either in their jaws or attached to the spinnerets. If a female loses an egg sac, she makes searching movements and may pick up a pebble or a piece of paper and attach it to the spinnerets.(Encyclopedia Encarta)

[GODsubmitter]

So, what is the conclusion about Aidid's errors gentlemen?

[TheNabi]

Peace

That he is prone to errors as we all are.

Joe

[good logic]

Wise words from "TheNabi" and the truth.

Peace.

[357]

I think the goodness of his work is enough for enyone. Just to be able to give people the one belief that the quran isn't perfect and has been messed with is enough in ones life time and his work has done that for many of us.

Thanks Aididsafar,

[GODsubmitter]

I think the goodness of his work is enough for enyone. Just to be able to give people the one belief that the quran isn't perfect and has been messed with is enough in ones life time and his work has done that for many of us.

Thanks Aididsafar,

I agree, also giving thanks to Aidisafar!

[loli]

Salam

Im in the opinion that the basis of the Arabs have distorted the meaning of words in the Quran have no basis from the Quran itself;

However it is explained in the Quran that the Jews and other nation/race(qawm) that have not come to the Prophet have distorted meaning of words. Aidid Safar is no Arab.

5:41 Muhammad Ahmad/Samira
You, you the messenger, do not be saddened (by) those who quicken/speed in the disbelief, from those who said: "We believed" with their mouths, and their hearts/minds did not believe, and from those who repented/Jews (who are) often listening/hearing to the lie/falsehood, (and) often listening/hearing to other nations (that) they did not come to you, they alter/distort the words/expressions from after its places, they say: "If you were given that, so take it , and if you were not given it, so be warned ." And whom God wants testing him , so you will never own/possess for him from God a thing, those are those who God did not want that to purify their hearts/minds , for them in the present world (is) shame/scandal/ disgrace, and for them in the end (other life is) a great torture.

The fact that Aidid have not complete his translation(stuck at Surah #2) after close to 10 years his book was first launch shows that something is wrong in his approach.