News:

About us: a forum for monotheists, and discussion of Islam based on The Quran

Main Menu

Does time exist?

Started by Tay, April 23, 2008, 12:36:12 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Well?

Yes, it is a part of the universe
3 (33.3%)
No, it is only a measurement of the relationship between two events
6 (66.7%)

Total Members Voted: 8

Lobster

Quote from: Wakas on April 25, 2008, 06:03:20 AM
I need some time to think about this one.

LOL Wakas now that was subtle! LOL
`What lies before us and what lies behind us is nothing compared to what lies within us.` - Emerson

'Phoenix! You are in Hot water, maybe you should change your name to Lobster.' - Khalil

Lobster

Okay so I haven't read any of the replies yet except Arnold's which I skimmed through mainly because it was short.

I expected most people here to go with the "no time doesn't exist" answer because it's more interesting and philosophical and different and against the norm and "out there."
But I've thought about this and to answer the question you have to define "time." What the hell IS time in the first place? Well, the only definition I could think of was "change." If nothing changes, it's like everything is "frozen in time," as one would say. We have time because we have change.
So then all there is is the present which keeps changing. The past is the present before something changed. So that means there is time?
What is time? that's the answer.
This is an interesting article from Discover magazine:
http://discovermagazine.com/2007/jun/in-no-time/?searchterm=time%20exist
`What lies before us and what lies behind us is nothing compared to what lies within us.` - Emerson

'Phoenix! You are in Hot water, maybe you should change your name to Lobster.' - Khalil

Tay

Peace Arnold, Lobster, all,

Lobster, the poll was triggered after reading this same article:

http://discovermagazine.com/2007/jun/in-no-time
QuoteEfforts to understand time below the Planck scale have led to an exceedingly strange juncture in physics. The problem, in brief, is that time may not exist at the most fundamental level of physical reality. If so, then what is time? And why is it so obviously and tyrannically omnipresent in our own experience? ?The meaning of time has become terribly problematic in contemporary physics,? says Simon Saunders, a philosopher of physics at the University of Oxford. ?The situation is so uncomfortable that by far the best thing to do is declare oneself an agnostic.?...

?One finds that time just disappears from the Wheeler-DeWitt equation,? says Carlo Rovelli, a physicist at the University of the Mediterranean in Marseille, France. ?It is an issue that many theorists have puzzled about. It may be that the best way to think about quantum reality is to give up the notion of time?that the fundamental description of the universe must be timeless.? ...

?I recently went to the National Institute of Standards and Technology in Boulder,? says Lloyd. (NIST is the government lab that houses the atomic clock that standardizes time for the nation.) ?I said something like, ?Your clocks measure time very accurately.? They told me, ?Our clocks do not measure time.? I thought, Wow, that?s very humble of these guys. But they said, ?No, time is defined to be what our clocks measure.? Which is true. They define the time standards for the globe: Time is defined by the number of clicks of their clocks.?

Arnold, you stated:
QuoteTime is created by the presence of movement of energy in any form, matters, rays, Quantum Field.

But the movement itself is the energy - the movement exists. The mapping/measurement of that movement (time) does not.

QuoteThe movement indiciates time.

I disagree. Time is what indicates movement.

QuoteIf there is no movement at all, then there can be no thoughts, no observation, nothing. So no time.

Exactamundo (minus the thought part). So, time, in and of itself, does not exist - just as observation does not exist. But thought does not require movement last I time checked.

QuoteIf you are talking about Alen being in space without anything, then for him, it seems time can be almost still. But it is not, because his thought-process is created through energy movement that is created through cause and effect, which is linear. Meaning, one thought succeeds another, thus time moving forward. So Alen's only indicator of time elapsing would be his own thougths.

I disagree. Without a reference point, one cannot measure anything. Imagine flying in a space shuttle but there are no planets or stars or any type of matter whatsoever. You could not calculate the distance travelled not the speed nor the time. You need a starting point or some point along the way to measure against. Without this point, you have no reference, thus you have no time.

QuoteI agree with you that God doesn not think. His knowledge was there always, so there was no need for thoughts succeeding one another, as there is no need for a learning curve. This is why He is outside time as All of His Being have always existed in the same infinite level. There is no increase in God. He is Samad, unique and self-containing and completely in balance.

:handshake:

Peace!
And you see the mountains, you think they are solid, while they are passing by like the clouds. The making of God who perfected everything. He is Expert over what you do. [27:88]

savage_carrot

QuoteBut thought does not require movement last I time checked.

But what about the neurons flashing/firing and all? My neurons couldn't handle the immense ramifications of this thread, so I just cherry picked a quote, I apologise...

QuoteIt may be that the best way to think about quantum reality is to give up the notion of time—that the fundamental description of the universe must be timeless.

Find this interesting...but quantum mechanics is the most counter intuitive thing there is, I will gladly give up trying to make sense of what it entails since it's likely gonna change anyways given some time...
God has a plan, Gaius. He has a plan for everything and everyone.

Supernaut

Read A Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawking. Great book. Nice and thin and surprisingly undull.

curtly

Just go to a hardware store and ask for a 'long weight' and all will be revealed....

zenje

Quote from: TayDoes time exist?
Yes, it's about 5:38pm right now. ;)
If they turn away, then Say: "God is enough for me, there is no god but He, in Him I put my trust and He is the Lord of the great throne." [9:129]

MUNZIR ALI

Yeah it exists...because of the the big bang...(creation)

MUNZIR ALI

Quote from: Supernaut on May 03, 2008, 06:45:37 PM
Read A Brief History of Time by Stephen Hawking. Great book. Nice and thin and surprisingly undull.
Yeah its great.. i read it! :yes