Messages

Peace be upon you!

With all due respect,

the reply I forwarded to sister Fadiva;  I based it upon my own opinion. I did not state that my response was divine knowledge. I also had a warning included. Had I researched the matter, I would have included verses from the Holy Quran alone, and it would not be as informal. Without a doubt, one should always research, reflect and trust in God before an opinion is formed.

Salam,

Yes, of course it's well understood. Don't worry.
May Allah guide us.

Salam

God bless you good logic.

Salam tutti_frutti

Contente de trouver d'autres francophones. 🙂

Salam, 

Je suis également française d'origine marocaine   
J'ai l'impression que le forum est moins "vivant" bien que pas mal fréquenté si j'en juge le nombre de personne qui consulté le site hors connexion. Je n'ai connu le forum qu'assez récemment et donc assez tardivement
par rapport à ses débuts.

Good logic, oui tu as raison bien sûr.
Si tu veux discuter (si discussion il y 'aura)avec nous en français, tu es le bienvenue.

Peace,

Of course one has to show verses.
I just don't understand the logic (for instance) of one saying plucking eyebrows like just a little hair is changing the creation of Allah while shaving the whole pubis is not.

Peace,

While wanting to ask question about traditional ablutions in a forum named "yabiladi"I found this question already asked by a member a few years ago and the answers (from different members)are :

- you have the fardhs in the Quran and the sunnan and as you know it is preferable to follow the sunna and the fardhs.
-while doing ablution according to sunna we surely do it according to the Qurqan
-why following sunna in this context is bad? The Quran gives clear instructions which are respected by the sunna
-the verse is clear, the face include eyes, nose and mouth and she adds two slice of verses from the Quran telling we must obey Allah and the messenger and conclude : "There is the Holy Quran which has been send to us but the prophet shows us how to practice rituals. "
- she is explaining to us that we should follow the way that is vaguely explained on the Quran and giving up the way that the one thought as if the prophet didn't understand what the Quran encompasses.
- Of course we have to follow the method applied by the prophet
-Look, being Muslim is believing in Allah and his prophet. If you obsession is to destroy the Sunna and rewriting Islam you are in trouble.
- who is the prophet Muhammad for you?
- By applying this hadith we apply this verse because Othmane's ablutions don't contradict the verse of the Quran
The face, the nose, the mouth, the ears are parts of the head.
- neither the hajj rituals are in the Quran, they were given by the prophet
.....

Then she was accused of pouring her hatred on sunis and sowing fitna.
That she had several accounts and was in fact an atheist against Islam...

She said that the verse is clear. She said also that she was accused of "innovation" while doing "ablutions" the way it is mentioned in al Quran.

The verse is clear, how can't a person see it as clear?
I realize that some people just don't want to follow just what they call fardhs in al Quran here but need other details. Hadiths are really important to them and I read someone telling the Quran and the Sunna (Hadiths) are  inseparable.

Here the link, but it's in French.

https://www.yabiladi.com/forum/ablutions-dans-coran-sunna-80-9814042-page=1.html

Roughly in another site about Islam it is said that there are 3 proofs of ablution:
From the Quran, from Hadiths, from muslims.

Salam,

Est ce qu'il y a des croyants/croyantes qui vivent en France. Gloire à Dieu, j'ai l'impression d'être tout seul.

Salam,

Je réponds assez tardivement vu la date de ton post. J'en ai croisé certains ici.
J'en fais partie, enfin je me défini comme musulmane et espère avoir une foi ferme inchaAllah. Allah sait mieux quant à ma foi. J'essaie d'en apprendre plus en étant aussi sincère que possible.

Si tu passes par ici (si tu fais partie des centaines de personnes qui visitent le forum sans se connecter, connecte-toi 😁). On pourra converser inchaAllah.

Peace YouTube,

Read 4.43, how do you understand " Fatayammamu sa3iyfan tayyiban famsa7u biwujuhikum wa aydiykum" ?

Peace the losttruthofislam, reel and Houriya,

If siyam is a spiritual retreat, remaining silent (not talking to other) and remembering God, why can't a sick person do it? 
But on the other side:
One can ask the same question about not eating but not drinking is quite difficult.

About travelling : nowadays why can't one fast the traditional way while travelling ? Stop talking  to someone and staying concentrated remembering God would be complicated while travelling.

Peace everybody,

I don't understand those who ask (asked here) for example "is sterilizing an animal transforming the creation of Allah" Which would be haram.
There are those who says plucking eyebrows is changing/transforming the creation of Allah" and when I say plucking or shaving the pubis is the same if I think the same way. I have as an answer like: "no it is different"    How?
And what about circumcision?
What about cutting tree to make furniture?
And what about all the thing used to build something?

Does the phrase "transforming the creation of Allah" include a list of things one can't "transform" ?

Peace Good logic,

So the sentence makes sense to you.
Ok. I understood it.
Callows is an adjective, so. Here it is used as a noun.

God bless you.