Messages

2024 update

Now each pdf is in word searchable format:
https://lanelexicon.com/updates/

(it was already word searchable but this is more accurate version I think)

Happened to read this today, pretty good, weakens a little towards the end but its possible a mainstream Traditional Muslim may not be so objecting to its content:
http://khalifathullahmehdi.info/articles/hadith/About-Hadith.pdf

The associated website has various articles also.

Also came across this today, interesting:
Decisive Sahih Hadith Content Check Project - The Sahih Hadith Bluff by Asim Iqbal 2nd
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pg-OPn0eYp0
(made by member here who doesn't post now)

I watched it a while ago. Some decent points here and there.

He was mentioned before here:
https://free-minds.org/forum/index.php?topic=9611019.msg441456#msg441456

Simply having "al" in front of a word does not make it a title or name in Arabic.

The meaning of the word is its primary significance, not as a title/name. When Quran relates stories to us of past prophets it relates them to us in Arabic, and it commonly mentions them or their contemporaries using the words "muslim" for example but obviously the past prophets were not speaking Arabic they would have used whatever was the equivalent in their language at the time. Let's say it was "jimmyjambob". Assigning any kind of specialness to "jimmyjambob" then exposes the ridiculousness of treating it as a title first and foremost.

https://misconceptions-about-islam.com/misconception.php?id=41

http://www.studyquran.co.uk/PRLonline.htm
aslama vb. (4)
perf. act. 2:112, 2:131, 3:20, 3:20, 3:20, 3:83, 4:125, 5:44, 6:14, 27:44, 37:103, 49:14, 49:17, 72:14
impf. act. 6:71, 16:81, 31:22, 40:66, 48:16
impv. 2:131, 22:34, 39:54
n.vb. 3:19, 3:85, 5:3, 6:125, 9:74, 39:22, 49:17, 61:7
pcple. act. 2:128, 2:128, 2:132, 2:133, 2:136, 3:52, 3:64, 3:67, 3:80, 3:84, 3:102, 5:111, 6:163, 7:126, 10:72, 10:84, 10:90, 11:14, 12:101, 15:2, 16:89, 16:102, 21:108, 22:78, 27:31, 27:38, 27:42, 27:81, 27:91, 28:53, 29:46, 30:53, 33:35, 33:35, 39:12, 41:33, 43:69, 46:15, 51:36, 66:5, 68:35, 72:14

peace Fusion, all,

Let us try a thought experiment:

Let's say you are actually living at the time of prophet Muhammad and you are in the audience when the prophet himself is reciting to you Al Quran.

How do you know what is being said is Al Quran or how are you going to determine what this man is reciting before you is actually revelation from God?

I recommend:
https://mypercept.co.uk/articles/meaning-hajj-Quran.html

Then this if one has time:
https://mypercept.co.uk/articles/meaning-masjid-al-haram-Quran.html

So if that's your three strongest points then I dont need to read the article, thanks.

I recommend:
https://mypercept.co.uk/articles/meaning-hajj-Quran.html
https://mypercept.co.uk/articles/meaning-masjid-al-haram-Quran.html

It addresses many points not even considered in the natural republic.

lol you just keep digging the hole deeper.

First, unusual approach.
Then takes scholars as infallible.
Then claims certainty (thus not need to check any counter evidence).


Quran, 25:30
The Messenger will say, "My Lord, This Qur'an was abandoned by my people,"

2:111
...Say, "Present your proof if you are telling the truth."

It's likely a technical issue to do with IP. Best thing to do is delete free-minds cookie, cache, then retry,

or use a clean browser.

 If that doesn't work you may need to try a VPN. It sometimes resolves itself