Brother what we are doing now and what RK was doing is exact same thing. Stop being a hypocrite. When RK learnt anything new he always changed his view. THIS IS A FACT. You don't know whether OR not if he was sincere because you are not God. And RK never claimed to be God. Bring me solid prove that he wasn't sincere. And you never be able to produce this since you cannot read minds and you have no knowledge of the unseen
ARE YOU GOD STUDENT OF ALLAH? CAN YOU TELL FOR A CERTAINTY IF I AND OTHERS ON THIS FORUM ARE SINCERE OR NOT??? THERE IS NO PROOF FOR YOUR CLAIM THAT RK WASN'T SINCERE!
Why are you asking me "Give me one single evidence that RK is GOD" He never said that he was GOD. What does that have to do with anything??? All he did was claim to be one of God's messengers! There is only one God , one creator. What I think you have a problem with is that you can't believe in a human messenger other than those that are written in a book. If this the case then I am sorry for you.
Shalom Aleikhem Kevin,
I would advise you to go back and read my last post. Specially where I quote myself and highlight a statement I made.
And the reason I asked about RK=GOD thing is to demonstrate to you "Straw Man Argument". Which you were doing. If you go back to my post and re-read it, you will see what I am saying.
To set things straight, for OBVIOUS REASONS, I do not know what lies in the heart of an individual. However, this does not give people the license to get away with any kind of lie in the name of God. I have already stated in my previous post that I would discuss the RK issue in separate thread, so let us not flood this thread.
And for the last time, please refrain from putting thoughts into my head and words into my mouth. What my idea of a messenger is, you can simply ask me. You don't need to make sh*t up and then refute your own made up sh*t. That by definition is the "Straw Man" style of argument. You are making things up about me, and then refuting them. I hope you arent doing that deliberately.
Instead of seeing it only through your eyes, why don't you try and see RK from my view. What is your opinion about Mirza Ghulam Ahmed ? (if you know him) For me the answer is same, either deluded( but sincere) or liar.
In any case, I do not wish to discuss it further for now. You and I will be judged on the merits of our deeds by God, same goes for RK and Mirza Ghulam Ahmed.
------------ Student of Allah