Critical Examination of Islam > Quranic Divinity

Quran alone interpreted according to whom?

(1/12) > >>

Tamara:
Is 'Quran alone' even possible?  This implies everyone reads words on a page exactly the same way with the same meaning.  Perhaps Quran along is actually the practice of each individual constructing their own compilation of Hadith from their own interpretations of Quran.

kgwithnob:

--- Quote from: Tamara on July 17, 2010, 11:55:02 AM ---Is 'Quran alone' even possible?  This implies everyone reads words on a page exactly the same way with the same meaning.  Perhaps Quran along is actually the practice of each individual constructing their own compilation of Hadith from their own interpretations of Quran.

--- End quote ---

The Prophet (pbuh) is commanded, throughout the Qur'aan, to FOLLOW the Qur'aan ALONE. Is it possible?

Peace,
Khalil

jaythikay99:

--- Quote from: kgwithnob on July 17, 2010, 02:23:30 PM ---The Prophet (pbuh) is commanded, throughout the Qur'aan, to FOLLOW the Qur'aan ALONE. Is it possible?

Peace,
Khalil

--- End quote ---


People are commanded, throughout the Qur'aan, to FOLLOW Allah and Messenger. Is it possible?

Wootah:

--- Quote from: RasulHamsa on July 17, 2010, 03:47:50 PM ---
People are commanded, throughout the Qur'aan, to FOLLOW Allah and Messenger. Is it possible?


--- End quote ---
When I read these conversations from my world view the source of the 'problem' occurs to me as the concept of Tawhid. My oneness of God and your oneness of God are different. This is exactly why sharia law rules Islam. No one in Islam knows God, he is unknowable other than he is God and he is one but everything else is probably some form of shirk. So yes I do think it is right to question whether - is it possible?

Tawhid. Who knew it could be so decisive.  :rotfl:

Jack:

--- Quote from: Tamara on July 17, 2010, 11:55:02 AM ---Is 'Quran alone' even possible?  This implies everyone reads words on a page exactly the same way with the same meaning.

--- End quote ---

Are you serious? How/where did you come up with such an outlandish implication?

This is like saying: Is God alone even possible? This implies that everyone views God exactly the same way...
Utter nonsense.

To those who missed it, Rasulhamsa's reply was clearly tongue in cheek.  ::)

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page